Krugman: Trump’s Tariffs Pushing the United States into Another Great Depression?
Left-wing economist Paul Krugman has once again emerged from the shadows to warn the American people that President Trump’s imposition of a 50 percent tariff on certain Canadian goods represents a “terrible mistake” — the very sort of blunder that he alleges plunged America into the Great Depression of the 1930s.
One might find such pronouncements terrifying if not for the inconvenient truth that Krugman, despite his Nobel Prize in Economics, possesses one of the most consistently unreliable crystal balls in the profession. His analysis remains captive to left-wing political ideology, where predictions often amount to little more than wishful thinking dressed up as scholarly insight.
There was a time when Krugman stood as one of the prominent economic figures in America. He enjoyed a twice-weekly column in the New York Times for some 25 years — a platform that amplified his voice across the nation. Yet even that perch could not shield him from the consequences of his own record. The Times eventually dropped him — though Krugman insists the departure represented his personal decision. He decided to retire. That claim fails the most basic litmus test of credibility since he now produces regular commentaries on Substack. If the move truly stemmed from voluntary retirement rather than editorial fatigue or irreconcilable differences, one wonders why the urgency to maintain such a prolific output elsewhere.
Krugman’s history of inaccurate positions and overt political bias stretches back years and provides ample reason for skepticism. He famously predicted that the growth of the Internet would slow drastically — a forecast that aged about as well as milk left on a windowsill during a heat wave.
Following the 2016 election of Donald Trump, he warned of a global recession “with no end in sight” — a dire prophecy he reiterated throughout the Trump years even as the economy boomed with strong job growth and low unemployment. Time and again, Krugman has sounded alarms about impending doom under conservative policies only to watch reality deliver the opposite.
His warnings on inflation from quantitative easing post-2008, the survival of the euro, and post-Brexit economic collapse similarly missed the mark. It seems that whenever left-wing narratives demand panic, Krugman stands ready with charts and certitude, only for events to expose the ideology driving the ink. He is the economic version of former Vice President Al Gore, who predicted Draconian climate catastrophes that never happened.
In the current case, Krugman dismisses Trump’s explanation that the tariffs respond to unfair trade practices by Canada. Instead, he offers the improbable notion that the measures arise from all that smoke drifting across the border from Canadian wildfires — a theory one might charitably describe as creative.
Whatever the motivation, Krugman declares the tariffs “almost surely illegal.” (“Almost surely? That is the kind of precision that we have come to expect from folks who live in ivy-covered towers. But I digress.) One imagines Krugman peering into his econometric models and emerging with probabilistic legalese that constitutional lawyers and federal courts might find presumptuous. He possesses no special qualification to render such judicial pronouncements. Those determinations belong to experts in law and Supreme Court justices, not economists wielding political agendas.
While this writer generally opposes tariffs on principle, they are occasionally necessary as a temporary means to correct imbalances or address illegal or unfair trade practices. In such cases, they protect American workers without triggering catastrophe — a reality Krugman’s partisan lens refuses to acknowledge. His reflexive opposition to Trump policies fits a familiar pattern — economic analysis subordinated to partisan warfare.
(By way of clarification, this writer does believe that Trump goes too far in imposing tariffs – and for many of the wrong reasons. Conversely, this writer does not agree with Krugman in terms of the dire consequences he forecasts. And so far, this writer has been right and Krugman has been wrong.)
Americans have grown weary of these recycled doomsday scenarios from voices like Krugman. The Nobel Prize, once a mark of intellectual rigor, now serves more as a reminder that even decorated economists can prioritize ideology over evidence. President Trump’s approach prioritizes fairness and reciprocity in trade, rejecting the naive assumptions of globalist orthodoxy that have disadvantaged American industries for decades.
As the economy continues to demonstrate resilience, one expects Krugman to pivot seamlessly to the next apocalyptic forecast. His Substack audience may applaud the consistency of his worldview, but the rest of the nation has learned to view such predictions with the skepticism they richly deserve. In the arena of economic commentary, Paul Krugman remains the gift that keeps on giving — primarily to those who appreciate the humor in watching failed prophecies accumulate like unpaid tariffs on Canadian lumber.
So, there ‘tis.

I do not follow Krugman especially when he politicizes. I live by the story: a great economist was once asked if he could accurately state the causes for the next recession. His answer was: “sure I can, just give me a few days after it ends.”
Larry points out the fact well-documented, that Krugman has many wrong predictions. He has even penned apologies for a good number, perhaps a policy PBP could adopt.
Larry also has stated he advocates many Trump policies, he does not favor tariffs, but he likes Trump policies. He has penned no apologies for that, or any part of it.
The problem is, like the Biden economy, the Trump economy is mixed with Trump and his oligarch
buddies raking it in while others are finding it hard to balance budgets as energy costs, healthcare costs rise to levels not seen for a long time.
Trump is capriciously, petulantly, applying tariffs as punishment to foreigners but, in reality it’s punishment to everyday Americans in order to reduce Trump’s record-level deficit because of wasteful spending on a war of choice, vanity projects, and grift. He sees a great Canadian evil that can only be cured by artificially raising their prices to you, the little guy. His real goal is to replace or heavily augment income tax revenues to ultimately claim he can reduce your income taxes while really just playing the old shell game to hide the pea that is what you pay him to govern. He is noted for favoring McKinley, another tariff lover with no legacy. This is taxation without representation, Trump wouldn’t dare a vote. TACO and that ain’t no TDS. Because TDS only exists as Larry’s refuge for rationalizing the stupidity that is Trump. Trump is the one with an enemies list. Trump who favors the rich, rewarded them, and told the rest of the country to suck pondwater.
The U.S. economy is currently in a state of mixed signals, showing positive, but weak gross domestic product (GDP) growth of 2% during Trump and consumer spending good in 2025 but K-shaped curve where the rich are happy, the rest no so much, and now slowing dramatically in 2026. Trump is also battling stubborn 3.5+% inflation and a cooling labor market.
Our economic growth is slow but relatively steady yet fueled not by the normal consumer spending, the steady part, but by AI-related investments, the minimal growth part. A bubble perhaps?
Unemployment is too high, around 4.5%, but not terrible but underscored by many leaving the rolls so not being counted anymore.
We are still the best economy in the world but much of that is due to us selling out to create quick gains at the cost of future generations. We lease out our national resources mowing down the pristine for what we now call progress; we frack and stuff with impunity by removing ecological constraints. Drill baby drill, clearcut mother, clearcut, frack me, frack you. Event Horizon is on the horizon again. And in true oligarch style we even lease out public lands for them to build their parkland palaces literally enclosing entire parks, millions of acres, and removing much national resources from the people.
One economist summed up the American success: “It’s the cleanest shirt in a very filthy laundry.
The main stats I look at revolve around debt and gdp. The traditional feeling is that 100% debt to gbp ratio is dangerous territory as your debt is now equal to a full years gdp and there may be issues with you paying off your debt. Sixty percent is considered prudent. We cleared 100% after WWII and the Greatest Generation thought it so important that they worked it down for over 30 years to less than 35%. And then came Reagan who changed direction after over 30 years of downward momentum. Larry pitched Reaganomics for a living. Nice job. Historic change in direction.
Obama went over 100% in 2013 after the Republican Bush’s Great Recession; the first time since after WWII started in 1946 at the peak of the rise of the Republican Reagan. The Greatest Generation had attacked it and brought it to 33% in the early 70’s when the archetype of modern debtor, Ronald Reagan began the upwards trajectory in the early 80’s. We never looked back.
Obama got scared, by 2015 got it to 98%, Trump took over and in his first year brought it up to 103%, did not get scared, and left office at 124%, a new record. Biden was scarred, got it to 115% in 2022, but today the Felon King has us at 123% in Q1@026, trying for yet another record. Trump is too stupid to be scared. Larry it appears too is not scared and we know he isn’t stupid, just ideologically frozen seeing party before facts. His TDS blinds him to our economic truth. We are running up too big a tab and payment will looks to be a reckoning.
No one knows the tipping point, obviously not 100%, but you can guarantee when it tipS, it falls, and creditors will be gone and we will be left holding a bag of worthless dollars with no one able or willing to help. That’s how our dollar and republic will end when no one wants to support our dollar, our way of life, our economy. I think at that point, Larry’s fear of possible recession will be the least of our worries.
Why it hasn’t fallen is anyone’s guess but the bottom line is we are still the best bet in town, the best economy, and we still pay our bills. Investors still trust us. Of course, the Felon King is known for not paying his bills on time or fairly, or at all.
The tariffs are illegal, immoral, and stupid. You don’t need Krugman or Larry to tell you what your wallet is screaming about. You can just look at your prices as determined by a dollar with lower value under Trump, twice now. Non-stop spending during war does not help. And you can look to his cost cuts where he is spending more this year than last, spending more than anyone since 2021, the end of covid.
These two numbers, spending and revenue, both going the wrong way, portend a negative economic future at some point. There are bubbles, one is AI investment, which is buffering the economy and the stock market but can disappear in a heartbeat. Not that Trump’s oligarchs have hearts. Housing sales, a key driver of consumer sales, have been stagnant since 2022 and are faltering under Trump. Gasoline sales in gallons have fallen under Trump as people pull back, cut costs, look for cheaper alternatives.
Where we are is people are cutting back voluntarily to make ends meet. How long they can last, who knows. If it gets worse, they will be the first to go; they are already on the edge.
The fact is I, and others, stand amazed that we are not in recession yet, but the traditional measurement of recession means you know it 2 or 3 quarters before the measurement confirms it. Consumer debt at an all-time record high under Trump, foreclosures up 71% 2020 to 2025 and in first half 2026 up 21% from 2025 with Florida, South Carolina, and Indiana, all Red States leading the pack. These states offer precious little in social safety nets. Bankruptcies are up 11% under Trump. Trump has brought us the weakest job growth numbers since 2020, the last time he delivered that blow. This blow is now softened statistically as many give up and go off the roles.
Folks, you can read it in the tea leaves, the tracks are on TV, you don’t need a weatherman, Horist, or Krugman to know which way the wind blows and while this economy still is standing strong, it certainly is not strong for you and I; it is strong for Trump and his friends. Let them build ballrooms, let them eat cake, let them suck on it.
We won’t be fooled again; economic life was better under Biden. We are earning less, spending more than yesterday for the same stuff, being taxed more with tariffs, cutting back whenever and wherever we can, and have an economy bolstered by oligarch spending on AI investment bubble and taking all those profits home. A prime example is vacation spending growth, growing to a trickle under Trump and the growth is really negative when you extract Trump’s inflation tax. That’s a big tell that any American can see right in front of their eyes as the big guy says don’t worry, be happy, it’s all just great, never been better.
Don’t be fooled again. Krugman has been wrong many times, even admitted it. So what’s in your wallet and if it’s butterflies, vote Democratic for the midterms.
Frank you misspoke by calling trump a felon king. There’s plenty of worse felons than him. Eric Rudolph? Unibomber? Temptation McVey? To name a few.
Harold, just because you can name other criminals does not diminish the fact that Trump is a felon. Never will. Matter of fact, you legitimize him as a felon, a crook, in that you feel obligated to show us that there are worse felons in America than the felon you voted for: Trump.
There are also less felonious Presidents than Trump. All of them. Every one.
Hunter Biden has only 3 felonies: Trump and his company have 51 felonies. In your book, Hunter is “less bad” than Trump. And electable using your metrics on felonies and the Presidency.
James Comey, Letica James, Joe Biden, Bill Clinton, EJ Carroll, Hillary Clinton, Barak Obama, Powell, Cook, Willis, Smith, Newsom, Taylor, Krebs, and all the Democrats that were associates or visitors to Epstein’s planes or properties have no felonies. You targeted, investigated, and when charges filed, you dropped them. Therefore, using your metrics, every one must be better than Trump using your “grading” scale. Even though Trump ordered indictments, investigations, and smears against all of them. Every one.
Trump earned his felony convictions by standing up for America and beating the queen cunts. Twice. But the constitution allows him to serve. Thank God!!!!! So try real hard Dunger, and you might someday be good enough to kiss Trump’s ass.
Darren, Trump himself has been convicted by a jury of his peers for 34 Class E felonies, falsifying business records in the first degree. He concealed $130,000 in hush-money payments to adult film star Stormy Daniels ahead of the 2016 election. He hid it from voters and the IRS via falsified invoices, checks, and ledger entries. He did this to rig the election by buying/burying this news to hide it from his wife, his family, and the people to to rig the election against Hilary Clinton. In 1/2025, the NYS Supreme Court sentenced Trump to an unconditional discharge. Your side, specifically House Speaker Mike Johnson, Representative Jim Jordan, and Conference Chair Elise Stefanik claimed Judge Merchan a liberal hack with conflicts of interest; I guess you were looking for harsher terms or he messed up everywhere else but in Trump’s sentencing for his 34 felonies for hushing a porn star over a little spanking sex.
On top of his election-rigging-porn star spanking sex payoff felonies, The Trump Corporation and Trump Payroll Corp. were found guilty by a New York jury on 17 felonies in a scheme to defraud in the first degree, conspiracy, criminal tax fraud, and falsifying business records from a 15-year executive compensation tax-evasion scheme. Trump’s corporations had to pay the maximum statutory fine of $1.6 million.
On top of his felonies, personal and corporate, Trump himself was also held liable for millions for the sexual abuse of EJ Carroll as well as $83.3 for his defamation of her person. Yes, this felon is also a defamer of women. And when he countersued Caroll for defamation for calling him a rapist, the judge tossed the case stating, on the record, that Trump was, in common parlance, a rapist, a digital rapist, who most certainly slammed her against the wall, lifted her skirt, put his hand inside her panties, and pantyhose, and then cruelly jammed it inside her vagina. Against her will. After she said no.
This is just fact now, as a matter of law, as adjudicated, under threat of perjury, in a court of law, where he was held accountable by a jury of his peers, with the guarantee that there were Republicans on the jury, and they could have hung the jury for any of these felonies. They did not, they voted guilty, guilty, guilty, for 34 felonies, and then again for 17 corporate felonies, and then again for a sexual abuse felony and then again for defamation.
On top of that he settled for defrauding Trump University students. His charity foundation was shuttered for being his personal piggybank. He went bankrupt six times having the court wipe out his debt with taxpayers picking up part of the bill for his firing of everyone, stiffing contractors and other financial failures. Trump said: “On occasion – four times – we used certain laws that are there,” but he lied — it’s six times. Like the Iran military deaths, he changed definitions and counted three bankruptcies as one. “We used the law” does not change the fact that he went bankrupt more than any other President ever. More than other folks claiming bankruptcy. The fact that you can name other felons does not change the fact that Trump is a felon, 51 times over.
As to being a King — that indeed is an opinion and you are in your rights to have your own even if Trump himself, depicts himself as a King. Your side called Obama a king for doing less. Republicans frequently called Obama a “king,” “emperor,” or “dictator” criticizing executive actions and orders, particularly when bypassing Congress on immigration and gun control. Conservatives like Rand Paul, Ted Cruz, Jeff Sessions, and Vice-Presidential candidate Sarah Palin invoked the 1776 American Revolution against monarchy to condemn his policies. Donald Trump holds the Executive Order record for all modern Presidents only topped by WWII era Presidents.
We fought a revolution over a King’s taxation without representation. Trump’s tariffs are a modern taxation without representation, an act of a King.
He has started a regional war of choice while calling the cause of death for 20 of our kids, patriots all, part of an “excursion,” not even a war defending our nation. Only a King chooses his wars without the people, Congress, authorizing.
He put troops and secret police on our streets, sometimes murdering citizens in the process as masked men without warrants disappear humans. Only a King unleashes police and military domestically voiding State’s Rights.
I can list more but that’s enough for to form my opinion. Face it, you know he thinks he is smarter, stronger, better than all other men. He depicts himself in his own art as touched by God, like a King is the vessel of God. A king gets his power straight from God. Therefore, the king does not answer to the people, the parliament, or any other human group as only God can judge a king. IMO, Trump fits the mold and Trump himself believes this to be true as proven by his words and deeds.
The only thing worse than Trump being a felon is people who voted for a lying, cheating, failure of a felon to lead them forward. How’s that working for you? Lower prices? Less inflation? More jobs? Better salaries? Fewer wars? No new wars in far away places? Peace in our time at home? Statistically, things are better under Biden than Trump.