Congress Opens a New Battle Against Birth Tourism
The battle over birth tourism is moving from the courts to Congress.
After the Supreme Court rejected President Donald Trump’s attempt to limit birthright citizenship through executive action, Republican lawmakers are beginning a more focused campaign. Rather than trying to redefine who qualifies as an American citizen at birth, they are targeting the organized international system that helps foreign visitors obtain visas under false pretenses, travel to the United States to give birth, and leave with an American passport for their child.
Sen. Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee is leading that effort by reintroducing the Ban Birth Tourism Act. The legislation would make birth tourism an impermissible reason for obtaining a temporary visitor visa and would add birth tourism to the list of deportable offenses under federal immigration law.
This is the beginning of a legislative battle against an industry that has turned American citizenship into a commercial product.
What Birth Tourism Really Is
Birth tourism occurs when a foreign national travels to the United States primarily to give birth so the child will receive American citizenship.
Giving birth while visiting the United States is not automatically illegal. The fraud occurs when an applicant conceals the true purpose of the trip, lies during the visa process, misleads border officials, or uses a commercial operation designed to evade immigration scrutiny.
That distinction matters.
A woman who gives birth while visiting the United States with a long term, legally obtained visa is not the same as someone who pays tens of thousands of dollars to a company that arranges the entire process. Birth tourism operations often advertise American citizenship as the final product and then coach clients on how to obtain it without revealing their intentions to the government.
That is not an accidental use of birthright citizenship. It is an organized attempt to manipulate the system and gain influence in America (as in the case of the Chinese millionaires) or to provide an avenue for bringing in family members.
Federal Cases Exposed the System
The scale of the industry became clearer after federal authorities began investigating birth tourism networks in Southern California.
During the first Trump administration, the Justice Department charged 19 people connected to three operations accused of bringing thousands of Chinese nationals into the United States to give birth.
According to federal authorities, the operators instructed customers on how to apply for visitor visas, how to conceal the true purpose of their travel, and how to mislead U.S. Customs officials. They also arranged flights, housing, transportation, and medical care while charging clients tens of thousands of dollars.
Some of the customers were reportedly Chinese government officials or people connected to state institutions, including state-owned media and the Beijing Public Security Bureau.
The cases were important because they showed that birth tourism was not merely a collection of individuals making personal travel decisions. It had become an organized commercial system with recruiters, property managers, transportation services, financial arrangements, and detailed instructions for avoiding immigration enforcement.
The owners of one company, USA Happy Baby, were later sentenced to prison.
In another case, a company with operations in Miami and Russia charged clients as much as $49,000. Its advertising claimed that it had served “the wives of dignitaries, oligarchs and celebrities.” The company also advised customers on how their child’s citizenship might eventually help family members obtain permanent residency.
More recently, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott launched an investigation into a hospital that advertised childbirth packages in Mexico under the slogan, “Have My Baby in Texas.”
Each case points to the same problem. Birth tourism is no longer an isolated loophole. It is a marketed service.
Blackburn Begins the Legislative Fight
Blackburn’s Ban Birth Tourism Act is designed to attack the system at the immigration level.
“Congress must step up to the plate to protect the integrity of American citizenship,” Blackburn said after reintroducing the bill.
The legislation would amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to make clear that traveling to the United States for the purpose of securing citizenship for a newborn is not a legitimate basis for receiving a temporary visa.
It would also allow the government to remove foreign nationals who engage in birth tourism after entering the country.
Republican Sens. Ted Budd of North Carolina, John Cornyn of Texas, Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming, Tim Sheehy of Montana, Jim Banks of Indiana, and Rick Scott of Florida have joined as co-sponsors.
Blackburn described the goal as making it “crystal clear” that foreign nationals seeking admission for birth tourism would be both inadmissible and deportable.
That approach gives immigration officials a specific legal tool instead of forcing them to rely primarily on broader fraud statutes or administrative regulations.
Why the Supreme Court Decision Matters
The Supreme Court decision is important, but it is background to the new legislative fight.
The Court ruled that President Trump could not limit birthright citizenship through an executive order. The majority concluded that the Fourteenth Amendment and existing federal law protect citizenship for nearly everyone born on American soil.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh agreed that the executive order could not stand, but he also indicated that Congress would need to act if it wanted to change federal citizenship or immigration law.
That opened the door to legislation.
For Americans who would be uncomfortable repealing birthright citizenship, Blackburn’s bill offers a more precise solution. It does not attempt to erase a constitutional guarantee or create uncertainty about the citizenship of children born in the United States.
Instead, it attacks the fraudulent conduct that occurs before the birth.
Citizenship Should Not Be a Commercial Product
Birthright citizenship has deep constitutional and historical roots. It should not be casually weakened because some people have learned how to exploit it.
At the same time, preserving birthright citizenship does not require accepting organized fraud.
The proper response is to make birth tourism clearly illegal, dismantle the networks that facilitate it, prosecute the fraud, and deny entry to those who intend to abuse the system.
Blackburn’s bill begins that fight.
Congress will now have to decide whether American citizenship will remain vulnerable to an international industry that treats it as a product for sale, or whether the government will finally close the system that makes that fraud possible.

Are Birthright Citizenship babies also eligible for US Government paid $1000 Trump Accounts? Just wondering.
Reward: the answer is still that the Trump law for Trump bucks is extended to anyone born in America.
ICE will be arresting Trump any day now for birth tourism. Hopefully not while he is in a car.
Daniel Oliver, the esteemed journalist without a bio or resume, writes about Congress’s new battle against birther tourism as recommended by our activist SCROTUM judge Kanthaveitall. Oliver tells us Congress is more focused, they have defined the issue, we got federal cases, and citizenship should not be for sale.
Except, Congress and the President has been attacking this for three administrations, there is no change to the definition, and under Trump, citizenship is for sale; the Trump Gold Card is an expedited visa program offering wealthy foreign nationals and corporate-sponsored employees’ lawful permanent residency and a pathway to U.S. citizenship, subject to strict vetting and five years of continuous residence; just a mere million and you are in. As of today, one person has paid, and 350 are being “vetted.”
Oliver never provides any statistics or numbers as to the magnitude of the problem. He claims “It is an organized attempt to manipulate the system and gain influence in America (as in the case of the Chinese millionaires) or to provide an avenue for bringing in family members, bot offers no statistics and just three anectdotes, some are somewhat dated to conclude: “Each case points to the same problem. Birth tourism is no longer an isolated loophole. It is a marketed service.” Without statistics, with three convictions, not quite sure you can make that claim.
He does not mention that it is not a crime to have a baby in America. He does mention that the current solution is to curtail fraud in immigration documentation as well as any company facilitating it for profit. IOW – this is a workaround to the SCOTUS denial of Trump’s silly pushback on the Constitution as recommended by SCROTUM activist judge Kavanaugh. The crime is form fraud like not indicating a late-term pregnancy before entering the US. Much of the work of Trump and previous administrations is to restrict entrance to the US IF there is the possibility of birth and, obviously, lying abut that on the form is a punishable fraud. The claim is that these “having a baby in America” organizations go beyond facilitation of legal means and transgress into how to cheat and defraud to do the same. And like I said, three convictions, since 2017, not exactly a tsunami of fraud.
The real name of the game here is fear. And then loathing. For diversion from low polling numbers for everyday life in America. All to capitalize on frustrations giving you a convenient outlet for your anger and diverting from our domestic issues. Hate them and you might forget to focus on the real cause of your frustrations. First, you have to pick a target, foreigners are an easy target for us versus them: it’s them that’s stealing my cheese. In this one, Oliver picks China, a current fav, Russia (uh oh, that could be trouble), and Mexico, a perennial fav. Once we have our target for hate, it’s loathing time.
Factually, the best number, a guess, is that birth tourism is less than .3% of all births in America. Not even a 1% issue. 85% of this comes from Hispanics, mostly Mexico, not China. These folks generally have higher level of education and skills than typical border jumpers.
CDC says 9,500 potentials in 2024 based on hospital records. Those are self-reports and no one knows how many did not report and how many are legal, but foreign. CIS, an anti-immigration 529 says 20,000 to 26,000 tourists’ babies a year. Many contest that number as overstated. Penn State researchers in a peer reviewed study, perhaps the most accurate number, say 5,000 to 10,000 a year. Bear in mind that IF the parents are still in America, that taxes are being paid and really not much drain on our benefits. Does not make it legal, just not that big a financial drain as in they are NOT stealing your cheese.
There are 3,600,000 births a year. The Penn State study notes: “The majority of such births are to Hispanic mothers, particularly from Mexico. The Mexican mothers’ above-average levels of education do not align with the narrative that they gave birth in the U.S. to access public benefits, Penn State researchers found. The number of such births among Asian mothers remains consistently low. From 2014 to 2024, the figure peaked at 425 in 2018, never exceeding 0.2% of U.S. Asian births.” There are 42,000 agents working ICE issues like birth tourism; that’s 10% of the size of every policeman on all of the police forces in America. There’s 50,000 service people deployed to the Iran region. What can I say: we got to find things for ICE to do.
As far as I can tell, the past three administrations have gone after birth tourism businesses. In March of 2015, in Irvine CA, authorities closed down a birth tourism business that charged pregnant women $50,000 for lodging, food and transportation.
Oliver’s 19-person Chinese birth tourism case is from 2019 and may be connected to the 2015 cases. In total, three people were convicted and the other 16 escaped, probably to China.
The Miami case is under investigation and no one has been indicted. It is not illegal to help people navigate our legal and immigration systems: ask any lawyer. Fraud about it is illegal. The investigation started in May of this year.
The Texas investigation just got underway.
Not exactly burning down the house yet on this; could there be a reason? Perhaps that the numbers are low. Oh well, ICE needs something to do. I just hope this does not become another series of sensational tabloid stories without convictions which is what Oliver has chronicled so far.
Again, arrest all lawbreakers honoring the rule of law at all times. Unfortunately, ICE is not really great at that.
Dunger that’s quite a word salad. Whatever you were talking about.
If you figure it out, let me know. It may be code to find the Holy Grail.
Farty, Joe,
It’s an indictment of our education system and social media lifestyle that the average American has difficulties with over 200 characters of text.
Congratulations on being average and totally adequate.
I spell my name: D A N G E R and I can read entire stories in The New Yorker and the Times. Too long for you chaps.