In a move that has sent shockwaves through the political landscape, the House Oversight Committee, led by Chairman James Comer (R-Ky.), has launched an investigation into Minnesota Governor Tim Walz’s alleged connections with China. The timing of this investigation is particularly significant, as Walz has recently been announced as the Democratic vice-presidential nominee alongside Kamala Harris. The investigation raises serious questions about whether Walz, a seasoned politician with deep ties to China, has been compromised by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) through a strategy known as “elite capture.”
A History of Engagement or Compromise?
Governor Walz’s relationship with China spans decades, beginning with his first visit in 1989 when he taught English in Foshan, shortly after the Tiananmen Square massacre. Since then, Walz has reportedly visited China over 30 times, an unusually high number of trips for a U.S. politician not directly involved in foreign policy. These visits, according to Rep. Comer, form part of a broader pattern of engagement that may have left Walz vulnerable to CCP influence operations.
One of the key concerns highlighted by Comer is Walz’s role in facilitating educational exchanges between the U.S. and China. In the early 1990s, Walz organized trips to China for high school students, and in 1994, he established a private company, Educational Travel Adventures, Inc., to coordinate these trips. This company, which reportedly operated until 2003, was dissolved just four days after Walz took office as a U.S. Congressman in 2007. Comer has pointed to these activities as potential avenues through which the CCP could have cultivated a relationship with Walz, leveraging his influence over young American students and future leaders.
The Technique of Elite Capture
The crux of the Oversight Committee’s investigation revolves around the concept of “elite capture,” a strategy employed by the CCP to co-opt influential figures in political, cultural, and academic circles. The goal of elite capture is to subtly influence these individuals, who in turn, can sway public opinion and policy in ways that benefit the Chinese regime. This strategy is insidious because it often operates under the radar, with targets unaware that they are being manipulated.
Examples of elite capture are not limited to Walz. In recent years, concerns have been raised about the CCP’s influence on university campuses across the United States through Confucius Institutes—educational programs ostensibly aimed at promoting Chinese language and culture. However, these institutes have been criticized for their role in spreading CCP propaganda and suppressing academic freedom. Similarly, there have been allegations that prominent business leaders and politicians have been compromised by lucrative deals and partnerships with Chinese entities, leading them to adopt positions that align more closely with Beijing’s interests.
In the case of Governor Walz, Comer’s investigation seeks to determine whether his extensive engagement with China, including his fellowship at Macau Polytechnic University and his participation in events alongside senior Chinese officials, represents an example of elite capture. Of particular concern is Walz’s role in speaking at the 27th National Convention for the U.S.-China Peoples Friendship Association in Minnesota in 2019, where he shared the stage with the President of the Chinese People’s Association for Friendship with Foreign Countries (CPAFFC). The U.S. State Department has identified CPAFFC as a Beijing-based organization tasked with “co-opting subnational governments” and influencing state and local leaders to promote the CCP’s global agenda.
FBI Involvement and Potential Compromise
Recognizing the gravity of the situation, Chairman Comer has formally requested the FBI’s involvement in the investigation. In his letter to FBI Director Christopher Wray, Comer emphasized that the Committee is concerned about the depth of Walz’s ties to CCP-connected entities and officials. Comer’s letter specifically requests that the FBI provide all relevant documents and information related to any Chinese entities or individuals with whom Walz may have engaged or partnered. The request also includes any records of warnings or guidance provided to Walz by the FBI regarding the risks of engaging with the CCP or its proxies.
Comer’s concerns are not unfounded. According to FBI briefings provided to the Oversight Committee earlier this year, the Bureau’s Foreign Influence Task Force is actively investigating activities similar to those alleged against Walz. This task force is focused on combating foreign influence operations, particularly those orchestrated by the CCP, which are designed to undermine U.S. national security and influence American politics from within.
The stakes of this investigation are high. Should the FBI uncover evidence that Walz has been compromised by his connections with China, it could have far-reaching implications not only for his vice-presidential candidacy but also for the broader U.S.-China relationship. The possibility that a candidate for the second-highest office in the United States could be under the influence of a foreign power is alarming and underscores the importance of thoroughly vetting those in positions of power.
The Larger Implications
The investigation into Governor Walz’s ties to China is a stark reminder of the lengths to which the CCP will go to exert its influence globally. The concept of elite capture, once considered a distant threat, is now being scrutinized in the context of American politics at the highest levels. As this investigation unfolds, it will be crucial to examine not only the specific actions and engagements of Governor Walz but also the broader tactics used by the CCP to infiltrate and influence democratic institutions.
In his statement announcing the investigation, Rep. Comer left no room for doubt about the seriousness of the allegations. “Americans should be deeply concerned that Governor Walz, Kamala Harris’s vice-presidential running mate, has a longstanding and cozy relationship with China,” Comer said. He further emphasized that “the American people deserve to fully understand how deep Governor Walz’s relationship with China goes.”
As the investigation progresses, it will be essential to determine whether Walz’s connections with China are simply the result of a long career in international engagement or if they represent something more sinister. The outcome of this investigation could have profound implications for the 2024 election and the future of U.S. foreign policy, particularly in relation to China.
ACZ Editor: It does not have to be a formal spy relationship for China to benefit from Walz’s emotional connections. The psychology of persuasion says that Walz is compromised by “commitment/consistency” meaning that because he has been sympathetic to China for a large part of his life, he will be sympathetic in the future, no matter how bad for the U.S. – because recognizing that he could be wrong about his perception of China’s benevolence is more difficult than believing his advisors and his own eyes when China turns treacherous.