Site icon The Punching Bag Post

Why Israel Deserves Praise

<p>Though Israel is rapidly losing support in the court of public opinion&comma; the reality on the ground should be causing an opposite effect&period; &nbsp&semi;The popular arguments against Israel neither reflect the true situation on the ground &&num;8211&semi; nor are they void of biased double standards&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Claim &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> Far more &&num;8220&semi;Palestinian&&num;8221&semi; deaths are reported than Israeli deaths&comma; so Israel must be acting unethically&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Defense &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> Espousers of such rhetoric are ultimately criticizing Israel for protecting its own civilians&period; The discrepancy in death has a great deal to do with the actions of each separate group&period; For instance&comma; Israel&&num;8217&semi;s emphasis on building bomb shelters and other safe zones is contrasted by &&num;8220&semi;Palestinian&&num;8221&semi; efforts to build invasion tunnels and offensive points of attack&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>To think morally about this&comma; we need to determine the difference in character between one group that uses human shields and another that is dissuaded from attacking enemy combatants due to the use of human shields&period; This distinction in character is&comma; perhaps&comma; the most important ethical factor to consider&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Claim &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> Israel&&num;8217&semi;s attacks on &&num;8220&semi;Palestine&&num;8221&semi; are far more damaging than &&num;8220&semi;Palestinian&&num;8221&semi; attacks on Israel&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Defense &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> Despite the rhetoric that Israel is a genocidal power bent on violence and destruction&comma; can anyone think of a militarily capable country under constant assault that has acted less severely than Israel&quest;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>When France was attacked by Islamic fundamentalists&comma; they began a practical carpet bombing policy of Syria&period; In fact&comma; the Syrian Foreign Ministry has written to the U&period;N&period; blaming French warplanes for the deaths of more than 100 civilians&comma; mostly women and children&comma; near the city of Manbij&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>To give a more regional example of this double standard&comma; let&&num;8217&semi;s look at The Guardian&&num;8217&semi;s coverage of both Israel and Saudi Arabia&period; A United Nations panel investigating the Saudi-led bombing campaign in Yemen recently concluded that there had been &&num;8220&semi;widespread and systemic&&num;8221&semi; attacks on civilian targets&semi; such action violate international humanitarian law&period; This information was provided by The Guardian in an intensely pro-Saudi article titled &&num;8220&semi;Saudi Arabia is bombing in Yemen to bring peace and stability&period;&&num;8221&semi; &nbsp&semi;More than 6&comma;000 people&comma; about half of them civilians&comma; have been killed since Saudi Arabia launched a multi-national campaign against rebels in March 2015&period; Why is Israel held to a higher standard than any other country in the world&quest; &nbsp&semi;To contrast&comma; the last few articles by the Guardian on the topic of Israel are listed below&colon;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>1&rpar;<&sol;strong> Hour by hour&comma; a hunger striking Palestinian journalist starves to death in Israeli custody<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>2&rpar;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong>Israeli tips Palestinian from wheelchair<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>3&rpar;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong>Palestinian support for violent uprising against Israel slumps<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>4&rpar;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;strong>Hollywood stars urged to reject free Oscar goodie bag trip to Israel<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>There seems to be an evaluation discrepancy in which Arab countries are granted far greater leeway than Israel&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Claim&colon;<&sol;strong> Israel discriminates against its Arab population&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Defense&colon;<&sol;strong> There is a good argument that Israel ethnically or racially discriminates less than any of its neighbors&period; In regards to Israeli Arabs&comma; many enjoy the religious freedom of being able to choose to be Jewish&comma; Muslim&comma; or Christian&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>If we look North to Turkey&comma; a NATO ally and potential member of the EU&comma; more than 4&comma;000 Kurdish academics&comma; mayors&comma; and human rights activists were arrested in 2011 alone&period; Hundreds of those arrested remained in pre-trial detention for months&period; As if false arrests were not bad enough&comma; the year of 2013 brought with it a law that Kurdish speakers would have to pay their own translation fees in court&period; A similar act in Israel would merit front page news&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>According to the International Campaign for Sunni Prisoners in Iran&comma; &&num;8220&semi;Thousands of Sunni converts are arrested this year for preaching Sunni beliefs during Ramadan&period;&&num;8221&semi; &nbsp&semi;Many of the affected Sunni Muslims will face the vague charge of &&num;8220&semi;enmity against God&comma;&&num;8221&semi; which carries with it the punishment of being hung by a crane&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Now&comma; despite the hypocrisy of standing by Iran and Turkey while condemning Israel&comma; the greatest difference between these systems is in the respective court system&period; When there are issues in question&comma; such as the case of the Separation Barrier&comma; the Israeli High Court ruled that the route caused disproportionate harm to &&num;8220&semi;Palestinians&&num;8221&semi; and must be changed&period; There are actually mechanisms within Israel to tackle issues of discrimination&period; Such a pro-&&num;8220&semi;Palestine&&num;8221&semi; ruling is hardly a novelty in Israel&&num;8217&semi;s high court&comma; but&comma; could we find any similar court in Israel&&num;8217&semi;s &nbsp&semi;human rights abusing neighbor states&quest;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Claim &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> A state based on a religion is a bad idea&comma; and the policy of allowing any Jew into Israel is unfair to Israeli born &&num;8220&semi;Palestinians&&num;8221&semi; who are not allowed to return to the country&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Defense &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> In a region where it&&num;8217&semi;s explicitly criminal to practice or abstain from the practice of specific religions in many countries&comma; the idea of a democratic&comma; Jewish homeland doesn&&num;8217&semi;t seem like the worst idea in the region&period; As a matter of fact&comma; from Europe to the Middle East&comma; there has been ambivalence over whether or not Jews are slaughtered like sheep&period; Don&&num;8217&semi;t forget that the only Nazi to be excommunicated by the Catholic Church was Joseph Goebbels &ndash&semi; and that was for marrying a protestant&period; &nbsp&semi;As writer Christopher Hitchens once said on the topic&comma; &&num;8220&semi;after all&comma; there are standards for these things&period;&&num;8221&semi; Other than the United States and the worldwide movement of pro-&&num;8220&semi;Palestine&&num;8221&semi; supporters&comma; who could forget Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei&&num;8217&semi;s recent book about destroying Israel&quest; &nbsp&semi;If we&&num;8217&semi;re looking far enough back into history&comma; many countries &ndash&semi; Iraq being the most commonly used example &ndash&semi; literally kicked Jews out of the country&period; Of all the religions in the world&comma; there is a better argument for a Jewish homeland than any other kind of non-secular state&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>If we consider the Holocaust&comma; there should not be a surprise that one of Israel&&num;8217&semi;s first laws was to open its borders to all those which met Hitler&&num;8217&semi;s definition of a Jew &ndash&semi; which was void of any specific religious considerations&period; If the &&num;8220&semi;Palestinians&&num;8221&semi; had accepted one of many territorial deals offered by Israel and refrained from threats to drive every Jew into the sea&comma; many of these &&num;8220&semi;Palestinians&&num;8221&semi; would currently be permitted into Israel&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Claim &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> If Israel cedes the West Bank&comma; the conflict will end&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>Defense &&num;8211&semi;<&sol;strong> If history provides any lesson&comma; let us recall the events which occurred when Israel left Gaza&period; &nbsp&semi;As is typical in countries with Arab majorities&comma; civil war broke out at the mere hint of a power vacuum&comma; leading to years of &&num;8220&semi;Palestinian&&num;8221&semi; on &&num;8220&semi;Palestinian&&num;8221&semi; violence&period; Based on serious security concerns and continued missile attacks&comma; Israel was forced to create a stronger&comma; militarized buffer zone restricting &&num;8220&semi;Palestinian&&num;8221&semi; movement and imports&sol;exports&period; Appropriately&comma; Israel is hesitant to make the same mistake with the West Bank &&num;8211&semi; an area in missile range of Tel Aviv&period; &nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><strong>In the interest of wrapping up&comma; let us quickly go over a few facts&colon;<&sol;strong><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The Egyptian leader denies the Holocaust&comma; but wishes it did happen&period; Jordan does not allow people with visible signs of Judaism on them into the country&period; Former KKK leader David Duke was permitted to spew hate on Syrian state media&period; Tunisian Imam Sheikh Ahmad Al-Suhayli of Rad&egrave&semi;s told his followers during a live broadcast on state TV that &&num;8220&semi;God wants to destroy the sprinkling of Jews and is sterilizing the wombs of Jewish women&period;&&num;8221&semi; A quarter of British Muslims think Jews &nbsp&semi;are &&num;8220&semi;responsible for most wars&&num;8221&semi;&semi; 40&percnt; say they &&num;8220&semi;control global affairs&period;&&num;8221&semi; Surrounded by hate and threats&comma; Israel should be praised for their civility&comma; character&comma; and restraint&period; The world must recognize the difference between savagery and civility &ndash&semi; and determine which they truly want to support&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version