Site icon The Punching Bag Post

When is an Award Prestigious? Is the Pulitzer Just BS?

&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">Years ago&comma; I was having dinner with a reporter friend&period;&nbsp&semi; I promised to give him a scoop on the yet unannounced winner of a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;prestigious award&period;”&nbsp&semi; I leaked him the name of the man who would be honored as the Portland Cement Man of the Year&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">For a prolonged time&comma; he stared at me in disbelief&period;&nbsp&semi; When he finally found his voice&comma; he questioned my sanity&period;&nbsp&semi; Did I really believe the Portland Cement Man of the Year was an important story – or that it was a prestigious award&quest;&nbsp&semi; He went on to explain to me that it is an insignificant story&period;&nbsp&semi; It was merely a narrow industry honoring its own&period;&nbsp&semi; He even referred to the award as &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;incestuous” to dismiss the scoop I offered him&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">After allowing him to ramble on for a few moments – providing all sorts of reasons why my information was beneath consideration &&num;8211&semi;I got to the point&period;&nbsp&semi; I put on my best inquisitive face and asked him how the Portland Man of the Year Award differs from … oh&comma; I don’t know … the Pulitzer Prize&quest;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">In fact&comma; every objection he gave to the importance of the Portland Man of the Year Award could be equally applied to the Pulitzer&period;&nbsp&semi; It is a narrow industry honoring its own&comma; for sure&period;&nbsp&semi; It is incestuous&period;&nbsp&semi; The only significant difference is that the folks who run the Pulitzer Prize are the same folks who run the newspapers that give the Award great coverage&period;&nbsp&semi; There is no end to the laudatory adjectives they apply to the Award – &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;prestigious&comma;” &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;coveted&comma;” &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;esteemed&comma;” &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;distinguished&comma;” &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;exclusive&comma;” etc&period;&comma; etc&period;&comma; etc&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">I have never been overly impressed by the Pulitzer Prize&period;&nbsp&semi; I offer three possible reasons&period;&nbsp&semi; &lpar;1&rpar; I am not generally impressed by awards&period;&nbsp&semi; &lpar;2&rpar; I never got one&period;&nbsp&semi; &lpar;3&rpar; I do not like their philosophic bias&period;&nbsp&semi; Three is the correct answer&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">In case you have not noticed&comma; the Pulitzer Prize is controlled by the most left-wing elements of the profession&period;&nbsp&semi; Any time there is a left-wing lean to a story or a book&comma; it is more likely to take home the Prize&period;&nbsp&semi; And the Pulitzer bias has gotten worse over the years&period;&nbsp&semi; Conservative columnist George Will won one in 1977 – before he joined the folks on journalism&&num;8217&semi;s <em>rive gouache<&sol;em>&period;&nbsp&semi; The late David Krauthammer &lpar;my personal favorite&rpar; won a Pulitzer in 1987&period;&nbsp&semi; But it is mostly left-wingers honoring … left-wingers&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">In the history of the Pulitzer the Prize has never been taken away or recanted – but it should have been&period;&nbsp&semi; One close call was when Janet Cooke&comma; of the <em>Washington Post<&sol;em>&comma; declined the Prize at the last moment after it was revealed she had fabricated her story about an 8-year-old heroin addict&period;&nbsp&semi;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">Alex Haley won a special award from the Pulitzer folks for his book &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Roots&period;”&nbsp&semi; It was later discovered that he had plagiarized part of his writing from the work of another&period;&nbsp&semi; He was forced to pay a settlement to the original author&period;&nbsp&semi; Pulitzer did not revoke Halley’s special award&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">The <em>Boston Globe<&sol;em> won the Prize for public service with a submission in which columnist Michael Barnicle was a key contributor&period;&nbsp&semi; IN an unrelated incident&comma; he was canned from the <em>Globe<&sol;em> for inventing a news story&period;&nbsp&semi; Yes&comma; that is that same Michael Barnicle who now pontificates regularly on MSNBC’s &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Morning Joe&period;”&nbsp&semi;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">There were calls to revoke awards in the past&period;&nbsp&semi; Once such case involved foreign correspondent Walter Duranty&comma; of the <em>New York Times<&sol;em>&period;&nbsp&semi; His report denied the atrocities committed by Joseph Stalin- including the starvation of millions in Ukraine&period;&nbsp&semi; Though his report might have been more aptly considered Soviet propaganda&comma; Duranty retained the Prize&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">More recently&comma; Texas Republic Congressman Lance Gooden sent a letter to the Pulitzer Board asking that the 2018 Prize awarded to the <em>New York Times<&sol;em> and the <em>Washington Post<&sol;em> for coverage of the mendacious Trump&sol;Russian conspiracy narrative be revoked&period;&nbsp&semi; It seems a substantial amount of their coverage was baseless&comma; and fact challenged&comma; as proven in the subsequent special counsel&&num;8217&semi;s Muller and Durham reports&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">The Prize is alleged to honor excellence&comma; but I see it more like the Scarecrow in the Wizard of Oz&period;&nbsp&semi; You will recall&comma; the overstuffed character was said to have a brain only because the Wizard bestowed a diploma on him&period;&nbsp&semi; The sheep skin was to proclaim his intelligence to the world&period;&nbsp&semi; So … does great journalism get the Prize&comma; or is the Prize merely a means of putting an arbitrary imprimatur of great journalism on favored writers with favored political viewpoints&quest;&nbsp&semi; I will leave that up to you to decide&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;&NewLine;<p class&equals;"wp-block-paragraph">So&comma; there &OpenCurlyQuote;tis&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version