Site icon The Punching Bag Post

HORIST: Kids are not leading the protests

<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">On March 24&comma; it is anticipated that tens of thousands &ndash&semi; perhaps even hundreds of thousands &&num;8212&semi; of students and adults will converge on Washington to demand that Congress do SOMETHING to address gun violence&period;&nbsp&semi; They may demand a ban on bump stocks&comma; although that is already in the works&period;&nbsp&semi; They will demand a ban on assault rifles&comma; although there is no such weapon&period;&nbsp&semi; There are only automatic rifles &lpar;already banned&rpar; and semiautomatic weapons&comma; which include most hunting and sports rifles and pistols&period;&nbsp&semi; So&comma; what is the SOMETHNG that can be done&quest;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">Apart from delving into the specific details of the gun and violence issues &ndash&semi; and they are two different subjects &&num;8212&semi; we should look at one of the descriptive themes of this future gathering&period;&nbsp&semi; It is said this latest anti-gun movement is under the brave leadership of high school students &ndash&semi; with the Parkland students in the fore&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">Making non-adults a part of political protest movements has always been a controversial subject &ndash&semi; and rightfully so&period;&nbsp&semi; This is particularly true if the elementary and high schools endorse&comma; encourage and participate in promoting youthful protest&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">There are a lot of good reasons for concern&period;&nbsp&semi; In a previous commentary&comma; I argued that the reports of the articulateness of many of the senior Parkland students should come as no surprise&period;&nbsp&semi; Young people are not without communication skills&period;&nbsp&semi; They do&comma; however&comma; lack a depth of knowledge on the complexity of public issues&period;&nbsp&semi; That is not to say they are ignorant but have not had the opportunity to get deeply involved in the political process&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">Biologists and psychologists confirm what every parent already knows&period;&nbsp&semi; Young people operate on an emotional system akin to fireworks on Independence Day&period;&nbsp&semi; Their passions of all sorts are easily tapped and effusively expressed&period;&nbsp&semi; <a name&equals;"&lowbar;Hlk509170435"><&sol;a>The lack of experiential knowledge and volatile emotions is what we associate with immaturity&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">It is the reason that we do not allow young men and women under the age of 18 to vote&comma; to sign contracts&comma; to join the military&comma; to purchase alcohol&comma; cigarettes and&comma; yes&comma; guns&period;&nbsp&semi; On many issues and in various states&comma; we do not grant the full rights of adulthood until a person is 21&period;&nbsp&semi; Insurance companies set higher premiums for drivers under the age of 25 &ndash&semi; the same age that must be attained for a car rental company to provide a vehicle&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">By law and tradition&comma; we do not allow our elementary&comma; middle and high school to participate in partisan activities&comma; whether those activities are related to our traditions of party politics or whether they are about controversial issues of political partisanship&period;&nbsp&semi; Civic education was &ndash&semi; with emphasis on &ldquo&semi;was&rdquo&semi; &&num;8212&semi; about structure and systemic issues of governance&period;&nbsp&semi; And where policies were discussed&comma; they were presented as a two-sided dialogue&period;&nbsp&semi; I made my debut in politics in my high school&rsquo&semi;s quadrennial mock presidential convention in which both sides of the political divide were represented &ndash&semi; and even at that&comma; it was an in-house educational event&comma; not a public demonstration&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">In more recent years&comma; kids have been involved in public demonstrations&period;&nbsp&semi; Not because of their contribution to the intellectual discussion&comma; but as props&period;&nbsp&semi; Pro-life families often bring children and infants to demonstrations as examples of life&period;&nbsp&semi; During teacher strikes&comma; school unions have organized young kids pleading to return to school &ndash&semi; with the suggestion that union demands should be met&period;&nbsp&semi; The women&rsquo&semi;s and &num;metoo demonstrations include young girls&comma; suggesting their futures are endangered if certain demands are not meet&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">Kids are basically props &ndash&semi; even older kids&comma; as in the case of the Parkland students&period;&nbsp&semi; The mantra is that on the issue of gun control&comma; kids are leading the way&period;&nbsp&semi; They are the face of the issue&comma; but they are not the leaders because they cannot be&period;&nbsp&semi; High school students do not have the time&comma; the organizational skills or the financial resources to lead a movement&period;&nbsp&semi; All that is provided by adults with an agenda&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">The current students&rsquo&semi; movement for gun control is given enormous media exposure&period;&nbsp&semi; They literally promote the events they purport to cover as news&period;&nbsp&semi; The Parkland movement was provided with tens of millions of dollars in free publicity&period;&nbsp&semi; Those students willing to take the hardest line against the NRA were interviewed on virtually every liberal news outlet &ndash&semi; even to the level of special reports and focus group segments&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">Students&comma; without any personal financial resources&comma; traveled by bus&comma; plane and train to state capitals and to Washington&comma; D&period;C&period; to serve as lobbyists&period;&nbsp&semi; In a sense&comma; they are actors on a stage that is financed&comma; produced and directed by adults with a partisan perspective&period;&nbsp&semi; In one of the iconic events&comma; a young student gave a highly partisan impassioned speech &ndash&semi; long on platitudes&comma; but with little substance&period;&nbsp&semi; He was an orator in the Kennedy tradition &ndash&semi; long on high minded platitudes and an emotional&comma; albeit imprecise&comma; call for legislative action&comma; but little of the detail and substance that involves complex issues&period;&nbsp&semi; Behind him was the puppet master&comma; Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer&comma; smiling and cheering from the platform he provided&period;&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">In New York&comma; Governor Andrew Cuomo surrendered all dignity to join in a carefully organized &ldquo&semi;student protest&rdquo&semi; &ndash&semi; chanting and shaking his fist as he looked around the young crowd for approval&period;&nbsp&semi;&nbsp&semi; In a move that borders on bizarre&comma; the suit and tie attired governor laid on the ground in one of those oft-featured &ldquo&semi;die ins&period;&rdquo&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">None of this is to suggest that these kids are not sincere or motivated by a desire to do the right thing&period;&nbsp&semi; And who can blame a teenager for seizing the opportunity to appear on television and to meet some of the most famous and powerful leaders in America&quest;&nbsp&semi; Apart from the seriousness of the subject matter&comma; these field trips are fun&comma; and getting away from school for almost any reason has a natural appeal&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">I was in Washington during some of the biggest anti-war marches &ndash&semi; hundreds of thousands of mostly young people&period;&nbsp&semi; Yes&comma; there were gatherings&comma; protest signs and speeches &ndash&semi; official and impromptu&period;&nbsp&semi; But most of the time&comma; it was a party atmosphere&period;&nbsp&semi; The smell of pot smoke was more prevalent than the tear gas&period;&nbsp&semi; Young men and women used the public fountains to splash each other &ndash&semi; sometimes sans clothing&period;&nbsp&semi; Many took their mantra&comma; &ldquo&semi;make love&comma; not war&comma;&rdquo&semi; literally and not always in private&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">While the kids are participating in what is part of the larger ongoing anti-gun movement&comma; they are not leading or organizing it&period;&nbsp&semi; They are temporarily fronting it for the well-established and well-financed anti-gun lobby&period;&nbsp&semi; Chicago Mayor Rahm Emmanuel&comma; who was once President Obama&rsquo&semi;s chief-of-staff once said cynically&comma; &ldquo&semi;never let a good crisis go to waste&period;&rdquo&semi;&nbsp&semi; The tragedy in Parkland is an example of that philosophy&period;&nbsp&semi; The Democrats left no time for a united nation to mourn the suffering and losses but turned the tragedy into a political subtext movement&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal">The left promoted those student walkouts across the nation&period;&nbsp&semi; School administrators and teachers endorsed and supported the walk out&period;&nbsp&semi; That placed our education system on the very slippery slope of political advocacy&period;&nbsp&semi; If students can be encouraged to take to the streets over one issue&comma; why not others&quest;&nbsp&semi; Already&comma; pro-life students want a walk-out&period;&nbsp&semi; In fairness&comma; they should be allowed&period;&nbsp&semi; Or can students only skip school for causes endorsed by left-wing educators<a name&equals;"&lowbar;Hlk509171049"><&sol;a>&quest;&nbsp&semi; There is a real danger that we are supplanting education with propagandization &ndash&semi; an issue already seen in our institutions of higher learning&period;&nbsp&semi; But at least college students are in the early stages of adulthood&period;&nbsp&semi;&nbsp&semi; This one-sided politicization of the classroom is a growing threat to the concept of a free republic&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p class&equals;"MsoNormal" style&equals;"margin-bottom&colon; &period;0001pt&semi; mso-layout-grid-align&colon; none&semi; text-autospace&colon; none&semi;"><em><span style&equals;"font-size&colon; 9&period;5pt&semi; line-height&colon; 106&percnt;&semi; font-family&colon; TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT&semi; mso-bidi-font-family&colon; TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT&semi;">Larry Horist is a conservative activist with an extensive background in economics&comma; public policy and politics&period; Clients of his consulting firm have included such conservative icons as Steve Forbes and Milton Friedman&comma; as well as the White House&period; He has testified as an expert witness before legislative bodies&comma; including the U&period; S&period; Congress&comma; and lectured at major colleges and universities&period; An award-winning debater&comma; his insightful and sometimes controversial commentaries appear frequently on the editorial pages of newspapers across the nation&period; He can be reached at <&sol;span><&sol;em><a href&equals;"mailto&colon;lph&commat;thomasandjoyce&period;com"><em><span style&equals;"font-size&colon; 9&period;5pt&semi; line-height&colon; 106&percnt;&semi; font-family&colon; TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT&semi; mso-bidi-font-family&colon; TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT&semi;">lph&commat;thomasandjoyce&period;com<&sol;span><&sol;em><&sol;a><em><span style&equals;"font-size&colon; 9&period;5pt&semi; line-height&colon; 106&percnt;&semi; font-family&colon; TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT&semi; mso-bidi-font-family&colon; TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT&semi;">&period;<&sol;span><&sol;em><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&nbsp&semi;<&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version