Site icon The Punching Bag Post

HORIST: Abrams falls victim to presidential response jinx

<p>Though it is considered a great honor and potential political ambition enhancer to be selected to give the official response to an address by the President of the United States – State of the Union and otherwise &&num;8212&semi; the outcome often falls far short of the potential&period;  It has almost become a bit of a political jinx that seems to have ended more promising political careers than it has launched&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>One only need harken back to 2009 and the response of Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal to a speech &lpar;not SOTU&comma; however&rpar; by President Obama&period;  As an Indian-American &lpar;of the kind that comes from India&rpar;&comma; Jindal was the bright new face of the GOP&period;  When his response came across more like a high schooler giving his first civics oration&comma; Jindal’s promising career seemed to slip off into political oblivion&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Former Kentucky Governor Steve Beshear decided to use a rustic setting – a small diner in Lexington&period;  He was surrounded by a lot of handshaking friends from down home&period;  Rather than a serious response to President Trump’s 2017 address to Congress&comma;  Beshear came across as a mix between Green Acres and the Beverly Hillbillies&period;  He got more ridicule than accolades&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The substance of Senator Marco Rubio’s response was overshadowed by a long reach for an off-camera bottle of water&period;  If Abraham Lincoln had experienced a sudden thirst at Gettysburg&comma; his words might have lived up to his expressed expectation &&num;8212&semi; that&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;The world will little note&comma; nor long remember what we say here&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The SOTU response jinx even snagged no less a political powerhouse – at least in name – than Congressman Joe Kennedy III&comma; grandson of the late Senator Bobby Kennedy&period;  The third’s speech came across more like an actor trying to play a Kennedy than the real McCoy – and then there was that embarrassing drooling&period;  His return to obscurity is reflected that he is not even mentioned as a possible 2020 presidential candidate&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>If you locked-in on MSNBC post-SOTU coverage&comma; you might be inclined to believe that this year’s responder&comma; Stacy Abrams – recently defeated for governor of Georgia – was magnificent&period;  That judgment&comma; however&comma; is based solely on the fact that she is a progressive black woman – which means she would have been praised by the fawning MSNBC panelists even if she had fallen down drunk after a few incoherent sentences&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>No … those with less sycophantic tendencies are likely to see the Abrams offering as yet another failed effort&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Abrams fell victim to a common trait among many responders&period;  She did not respond&period;  He speech was canned campaign rhetoric – and a bit obvious in its primary purpose of promoting her future candidacy for the United States Senate&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Abrams overly long introduction to her own up-from-poverty and the things-my parents-taught-me narratives were too obvious and too much of a political cliché&period;  In the political consulting business&comma; we call this the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;log cabin” story – you know&comma; the early memories of a dirt floor and no wood for the fireplace on those cold winter nights&period;  Ironically&comma; studies suggest that these iconic self-serving mini-biographies are of the least interest and credibility with the average voter&period;  To believe them is to believe that Senator Richard Blumenthal really served in Vietnam and that Senator Warren is a Native American&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>After completing her campaign speech&comma; Abrams did offer up a litany of Democrat talking points that had little to nothing to do with President Trump’s Speech&period;  Perhaps she was too busy rehearsing her response to even listen to Trump&period;  There was nothing in the response to suggest that Abrams had heard a word of it&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Abrams described American in familiar terms – but more suited to the 1930s than today’s America&period;  To believe her assessment&comma; millions of families are descending into abject poverty … factories are closing all across the country … people are losing their jobs&period;  Vast numbers of we the people are torn between paying the rent or buying our pills&period;  The only problem with his vision&comma; it is in no way the modern American reality&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>She peddled the slander of pandemic racism among the populace – presumably&comma; the white populace – and&comma; with unabashed hyperbole&comma; Abrams argued that voter suppression was a clear and present danger to the Republic&period;  She did not touch on deadly urban institutional racism that permeates our Democrat-controlled cities&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Finally&comma; there was the setting – the backdrop&period;  Democrats seem to have a problem with that&period;  In addition to  Beshear’s hokey rustic restaurant setting&comma; there was that hilarious response to an earlier Trump national address in which Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi did a great tableau of the famous American Gothic painting&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>For her venture into the vagaries of presidential response land&comma; Abrams selected a rather nondescript sterile image&period;  There she was at a podium that looked too similar to the one used by Schumer and Pelosi&period;  Architecturally&comma; it was a big empty space – no iconic pillars&comma; no cozy book-lined room&comma; no food counter&period; The scene was framed by American and State of Georgia flags&period;  Then there were all those folks in the background&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Who were they&quest;  Why were they there&quest;  Standing on a multi-level riser&comma; they looked more like a high school choir during a break in rehearsal than … than whatever they were supposed to be or represent&period;  Yes&comma; they were props&comma; to be sure&period;  But what was the message&quest;  Young Kennedy had used a bunch of Millennials&comma; but at least they hooted and hollered on cue&period;  The folks behind Abrams could have been an image on a billboard&period; Hmmm&period;  Maybe it was&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Whether Abrams will have a long and successful political future is undeterminable at this juncture&comma; but it pretty is safe to say that her response to Trump’s State of the Union Speech will not have helped&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>So&comma; there &OpenCurlyQuote;tis&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version